← This term

Supreme Court · 25-95 · Decided Jun 23, 2026

Pung v. Isabella County

The proper baseline for measuring “just compensation” following a fairly conducted tax sale is the auction sale price, not the property’s hypothetical fair market value; Isabella County did not violate the Eighth Amendment Excessive Fines Clause by failing to compensate the taxpayer for his property’s fair market value.

The summary supremecourt.gov gives with the opinion.

What the Court decided

The proper baseline for measuring “just compensation” following a fairly conducted tax sale is the auction sale price, not the property’s hypothetical fair market value; Isabella County did not violate the Eighth Amendment Excessive Fines Clause by failing to compensate the taxpayer for his property’s fair market value.

Where it stands

Decided Jun 23, 2026.

The summary is the one supremecourt.gov gives with the opinion. The opinion (PDF) ↗

Who wrote and who joined

Joined the majority in part: Alito, Roberts, Sotomayor, Kagan, Gorsuch, Kavanaugh, Barrett, Jackson, Thomas

Concurrence: Sotomayor (wrote), Gorsuch, Jackson

Concurring in the judgment: Gorsuch, Thomas (wrote)

Question presented

Isabella County confiscated the Pung Estate's private home for approximately $2,200 in taxes and fees (that were never actually owed). The lower courts used the artificially depressed auction sale price rather than the property's fair market value as the starting point for its damages calculation. The Sixth Circuit and others have held that the "fair market value" taken is not what is owed to begin to fulfill the constitutional compensatory obligation imposed by the Fifth Amendment. That defies this Court's precedents. And if it is not taken within the meaning of the Fifth Amendment, it is otherwise an excessive fine under the Eighth Amendment by imposing a punishment by pilfering far more than ever needed to satisfy a small debt.

The questions presented are:

1. Whether taking and selling a home to satisfy a debt to the government, and keeping the surplus value as a windfall, violates the Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment when the compensation is based on the artificially depressed auction sale price rather than the property's fair market value?

2. Whether the forfeiture of real property worth far more than needed to satisfy a tax debt but sold for fraction of its real value constitutes an excessive fine under the Eighth Amendment, particularly when the debt was never actually owed?

Word for word from the Court's question-presented document.

The Constitution, in the Court's words

Each provision the opinion of the Court names. ThePillory doesn't characterize the ruling. The sentences aren't quoted here: the text of this decision's PDF (the bound volume's preliminary print) can't be copied exactly. They're in the opinion.

From the Court's slip opinion as published on supremecourt.gov. This term · The justices