← About

Methodology

How ThePillory maps laws and issues to the Constitution, and how reports are reviewed.

In beta

ThePillory is in beta. Every fact links to its source. Found an error? Report it. A person reads every report and checks it against the original record; a fact that's wrong is corrected on the page, with its source. Records ThePillory can't tie to an official with certainty (by an ID, or a single match the source supports) aren't shown, and reports transcribed by AI from scans stay links to the report until a person has checked them.

Constitutional analysis of bills and executive orders

ThePillory maps the Constitution; it doesn't rule on it. For bills our officials have voted on, and for executive orders of the President and the Governor, an AI tool writes an analysis showing which parts of the Constitution a bill touches. Automatic checks and a second AI tool check every analysis; one the reviewer flags is fixed by a different AI model, shortened, or kept off the page, and nothing the reviewer marked as a factual error, unfair to one side or opinion stated as fact is ever published. A person spot-checks a random share. Nothing here is a verdict on whether a bill is constitutional, and nothing here is legal advice.

  1. Which bills get analyzed

    Bills with a final-passage vote in Congress or the California Legislature, and any bill an issue on this site links to. (Once residents can follow bills, followed bills will count too.) First, a quick AI check (Claude Haiku) reads each bill's title and sets aside ceremonial and routine measures, such as commemorations, awareness days, post office and building namings, and honorary resolutions. Each one set aside is logged with the reason, the bill page says why, and a person can reverse it. The same check rates how much each bill bears on this county (California, rural counties, federal lands, water, wildfire, roads and similar), so the daily limit goes to what matters most here. It judges by subject only, never by party or sponsor.

  2. Two levels: a short card, or a full analysis

    Most bills get a short card: a two to three sentence summary, the one to three most relevant provisions of the Constitution with one sentence each, and one sentence each for where the bill aligns, where it may be in tension, and why a departure might still serve the public. A full analysis covers every provision the bill touches, contested readings and what the analysis can't tell you. It's written when an issue on this site links to the bill, or when a resident asks for one with "Request full analysis" on the bill page. Both start from the bill's own words: the latest text on Congress.gov or the California Legislature's site, or the official summary, labeled "limited", when the text isn't available. For a short card of a very long bill, the AI tool reads the official summary, the bill's list of sections and its opening pages rather than every page, and the card is labeled "limited" with exactly what it was based on; a full analysis reads the whole bill.

  3. An AI tool writes it, and automatic checks correct it

    Claude, an AI model made by Anthropic, writes the card or analysis from the bill text and the full text of the Constitution. Its instructions: no verdicts on constitutionality, no party labels or partisan language, the strongest version of each view, and "uncertain" rather than a guess. Each card or analysis also has one line beginning "Supporters argue that" and one beginning "Critics argue that": the strongest argument each side makes, attributed to that side rather than to ThePillory, of similar length, naming no person, party or group. Then every passage quoted from the Constitution is compared with the National Archives text and replaced with the exact words if it doesn't match, and every court case is looked up in CourtListener, a free public database of court opinions. Cases that can't be found under the same name are removed, with every sentence that relies on them. Each change is logged.

  4. A second AI tool reviews it

    A separate Claude call reads the analysis against the bill text and answers five questions. Is the summary accurate and complete for what the bill does? Is any side's argument noticeably weaker or less charitable than the other's? Is opinion stated as fact, or is there loaded or partisan language? Are the chosen provisions relevant, with nothing obviously missing? Does anything claim more certainty than the sources support? Each problem it finds is rated major (a factual error, unfair treatment of one side, or opinion stated as fact, including any verdict on constitutionality) or minor (completeness, phrasing or style, including panels of uneven length that each state their view fairly). When any problem is found, the first AI tool gets one chance to fix what the reviewer named; the revision goes through the same automatic checks and is reviewed again. With no major problem, the analysis is published, labeled "AI-drafted, auto-checked"; any minor notes left are shown in a small note with it. With a major problem, it stays off the public page and goes to the next step.

  5. A flagged analysis is fixed, shortened, or kept off the page

    The reviewer also says exactly which passages each problem is in. A different, larger AI model (Claude Opus) rewrites the analysis to fix what the reviewer found, and every check runs again: the Constitution quotes, the court cases, the wording rules, and the reviewer. If no major problem is left, it's published as "AI-drafted, auto-checked". If one is, the flagged passages are removed, never reworded, and the rest is checked again. When removing a passage would leave one side standing without the other, both go: all three panels together, both "Supporters argue" and "Critics argue" lines together. If what's left still passes, it's published with a line saying passages were removed. If not, only the summary and the provisions it touches are shown, with "Full analysis not available yet", once the reviewer passes them; otherwise nothing is published. Text the reviewer marked as a factual error, unfair to one side, or opinion stated as fact is never published, even if a later check would pass it.

  6. Readers can flag problems

    Every published analysis has "Something wrong?". Choose a reason (inaccurate, unfair to one side, missing perspective, or other) and add a note if you like. No account is needed. The analysis stays up, marked "Under review", until the AI reviewer reads it again with your report (as a claim to check against the bill text, not an instruction). If it finds a major problem, the analysis goes through the same fix, shorten or take-down step above, and what changed and when is listed under "Changes to this analysis" on the page. To keep the forms free of spam, they use Cloudflare Turnstile and a daily limit per visitor. We don't store your address, only a one-way code that changes every day.

  7. People check the system, too

    Executive orders go through every step above the same way, from the order's own text (the Federal Register's, or the Governor's signed order), with the same instructions in the order's words and the same layout for every President and Governor; there's no relevance check, since every order is substantive. A random 10% of the analyses the AI reviewer passes also go to a person as spot checks; nothing waits on them. The review page keeps a running count of how often the person agrees with the AI reviewer, so we can see whether it can be trusted. A person can edit any part, approve, reject, or ask for a new draft. Analyses a person approves show "Reviewed by" with their name and the date. Earlier versions and every edit are kept.

Meetings and agenda watch

Meeting times, places, agendas, staff reports, minutes and video links come from Calaveras County's official meeting portal, for the Board of Supervisors and the Planning Commission. State committee hearings come from Open States and show when one of Calaveras County's two state legislators sits on the committee.

Every state

Congress and California are covered in full. For every other state, the District of Columbia and Puerto Rico, the records come in two parts.

The executive branch

The President, the Vice President and the Cabinet, and California's Governor and the other offices California elects statewide. Each record says where it comes from and links to it.

No scores, grades or commentary: counts of what's on the record, and the record itself.

Platform and promises

A promise is a specific, checkable commitment an official made: an action, a vote or a deadline, with an object, that anyone could later check happened or didn't. General values, priorities and positions are not promises.

Campaign funding and lobbying

Money and votes are shown side by side, as facts. ThePillory never says or implies that money caused a vote. A contribution and a vote can sit next to each other in the record for many reasons, and the data can't tell you why someone voted as they did. Every number says what it counts, the period it covers, and where it comes from.

How dark money works

"Dark money" is money spent to influence elections where the public can't see who first gave it. It's legal. Here is how it happens, in plain terms, and what ThePillory shows about it.

Money from government, travel and foreign agents

Money also flows the other way: from the government to organizations. ThePillory shows it beside campaign funding and lobbying as facts on their own. Nothing on ThePillory says that a project, an award, a trip or a contact was given or made in return for a vote, a contribution or lobbying, or the other way around.

Keeping records current, and checkable

Government websites move, change format and sometimes disappear. ThePillory checks every source each day, and keeps copies so that every source link still leads somewhere.

Data status: each source and when it last updated

Topics

Topics tie records about the same subject together: bills and how a place's representatives voted, county meeting items, executive actions, what officials say on their own Issues pages, and campaign money from industries tied to the subject. They're shown side by side as facts. A topic page never says that one record caused another, or why anyone voted, acted or gave as they did.

Taxes

The Taxes section shows who pays taxes, who holds household wealth, and what companies report paying, as published, without conclusions about any of them.

The Time Machine

A year slider on county, official and topic pages shows the page as it was in an earlier year, back to 1993. A banner on every past-year view names the year, with one tap back to today. Who held an office is shown as a fact, with party as plain text, the same for everyone. Each past-year view ends with a list of what isn't available for that year, instead of leaving blanks.

Elections

What's on the ballot, from official sources only, with a link to each. Every candidate and measure is shown the same way, in ballot order. ThePillory doesn't endorse candidates or measures, and doesn't publish polls, predictions or race calls.

Ballot measures and the Constitution

Each statewide measure on the November 3, 2026 ballot (California, Washington, Colorado, Arizona, Florida and Michigan) has a "Constitution" section with the same three parts, and one line: "This shows which parts of the Constitution each measure involves. It is not a recommendation on how to vote." Before the election there are no "Where it aligns" or "Where it may be in tension" panels.

Quick mode

The Quick / Detailed switch under the header shows a short card in plain words at the top of a page, with the full page one tap away. Your choice is kept in your browser only; nothing is sent to ThePillory, and you're never asked your age. The rules don't change: facts only, neutral wording, the source one tap away.

Stock trades by members of Congress, the executive branch and the Supreme Court

Members of Congress report their stock trades, and their spouses' and dependent children's, in Periodic Transaction Reports under the STOCK Act. ThePillory reads them from the House Clerk's financial disclosure site and the Senate's eFD site, and shows each trade as filed, with a link to the report. The same rules apply to every member, whatever their party.

The President, Vice President and Cabinet report trades to the Office of Government Ethics (OGE) on Form 278-T, under the same 45-day rule and amount ranges. ThePillory reads the 278-T reports OGE posts, shown with the same layout, and the official's position and agency as OGE lists them. Some reports OGE releases only on request (OGE Form 201): those are listed as "Available from OGE on request", with the request link, and their contents aren't shown or guessed. A 278-T doesn't always say whose account a trade was in, so owner is shown only where the report states it.

Some 278-T reports are posted as scans of paper pages, with no reliable text to read. ThePillory reads them with AI, and code checks each row on its own. An AI model reads the scan and copies every row exactly. A row can be published only when the report's own text layer (the scan's searchable text) shows the same date, amount and description, and a second, different AI model reads the row the same way: the date, the type, the amount and the description, letter for letter, with neither model marking it hard to read. Rows that pass are published without a person checking them first, labeled "Read by AI from the scanned report, auto-checked. See the original", and each one opens the original report. Any other row isn't guessed: the report is listed as, for example, "84 of 90 rows transcribed", naming the rows that couldn't be read with confidence and linking the scan. If the readings can't be trusted as a set (for example, they seem to have shifted the rows), nothing from that report is published. One in ten published reports is picked at random for a person to compare with the scan; a report found wrong is taken down, and anyone can report an error from the link at the bottom of every page. The same rule applies to everyone, the President included.

Supreme Court justices list their purchases and sales once a year, in Part VII of their annual financial disclosure report (AO Form 10), with the type, the date and a value range; they don't file a report within 45 days as members of Congress do. Since the reports for 2023, the judiciary produces them electronically with a text layer, and ThePillory reads each purchase and sale from it exactly as filed, on the justice's Disclosures tab. A report is read only when every transaction line in it is accounted for; otherwise it's listed as a link. The judiciary's own disclosure site requires a registration on every visit, so the reports are read from the unchanged copies Fix the Court posts, and each line links to that copy.

California's officials (the Governor and statewide officers, members of the Legislature and Calaveras County's supervisors) don't file trade reports. Once a year, each files a Statement of Economic Interests (Form 700), and its Schedule A-1 lists their investments in stocks, bonds and other interests, with the fair market value range and, when an investment was acquired or disposed of during the year, the date. ThePillory reads Schedule A-1 of each annual statement since 2023 from the FPPC's published PDF: the investment's name and description from the text the filer typed, and the boxes they checked by measuring the ink inside each box on the rendered page. A statement is read only when every entry passes the checks (exactly one value box, no box half-filled, whole dates); otherwise it's listed as a link. These lines are shown as "Acquired" or "Disposed", with the value range as filed, apart from the federal trade reports: a Form 700 gives an investment's value, not the size of a purchase or sale.

Net worth, as reported

An estimate of each person's net worth from their own annual financial disclosure reports, for members of Congress, the President, Vice President, Cabinet and the Supreme Court justices. The same method for everyone, whatever their party: facts from the reports, no commentary.

Candidates

Pages for candidates who aren't in office yet, with the same layout for every candidate: the race, the election date, Platform, Votes, Funding and More. ThePillory doesn't endorse candidates, and doesn't publish polls, predictions, rankings or contact details.

The Supreme Court

The justices, their decisions and this term's cases, from the Court's own records, with a link to each. The same layout for every justice. ThePillory doesn't label justices, score them, group them or predict outcomes.

Financial disclosures

Officials' own reports of their finances, listed with a link to each document. ThePillory lists these records; it doesn't summarize, score or interpret what's in them.

What a full analysis contains

A short card has the first four parts, briefly: the summary, the one to three most relevant provisions, one sentence for each panel, and contested readings only when a question is genuinely contested.

The Constitution's text

ThePillory quotes the Constitution and its 27 amendments only from one stored copy of the National Archives transcription, which keeps the original spelling (such as "chuse" and "Controul"). The full text is on the Constitution page, and an automatic check compares it with the Archives whenever it changes.

Reports and issues

Reporting isn't open yet: it opens when accounts launch. When it does, this section will explain how reports are reviewed, corroborated, and given a confidence level. How it works

How reports are reviewed, corroborated, and given a confidence level.